I have just looked at the article that "Big Al" gave us a link to and its pretty much as I expected, so I will put a few more of my own views here...Big Al wrote:Here's an interesting article and comments related to who actually owns the photographs one uses to sell on eBay. (I thought about posting this in the eBay thread, but decided it was more appropriate here.) Alan
"On eBay, who owns the photos that sellers upload with their listings? That's a question Brian Cohen posed on the AuctionBytes Blog in July, and we posed this question to readers in the form of a survey.
Brian felt that sellers owned their photos, but that once an item sold, the photo (if not watermarked) should become fair game for the bidder/buyer to use as they see fit."
Continued here: http://www.ecommercebytes.com/cab/abn/y13/m09/i24/s02
One contributor says he takes a lot of time over creating his pictures with resizing and cropping etc, and feels the picture is his copyright at the time of creation and then when that picture is used on an auction site, to show what the seller has to offer, he still has copyright, no the host of the auction.
This I feel is correct and the auction host should not and cannot, then take control of the use of that picture, unless permission is sought from the originator of that picture.
If the seller is selling something particularly rare and sought after, the auction host may want to use the picture for future illustratative purposes and it should be obvious to the host that permission should be asked and a royalty paid every time the host uses that picture.
Watermarking images is very popular but not totally secure, unless the mark is electronic or in the form of large words running right through the image.
In general, the sort of collectibles that we, on this forum buy and sell, are relatively common, its only the intricate details, or rare overall colours, that may make one model more desirable than the next, so as a guide for submitting pictures of models to an auction site, put the model in front of something that you would reconise again, on a sideboard or kitchen table with clutter on it, place the model on a very bright red or blue cloth or card, leave the clutter far enough behind the model so it is not in sharp focus, that way, the auction host is very unlikely to want to use that picture again and because of the background clutter, it is a simple copyright protection method and you would have issue with someone copying it, because you would, (or should) reconise the picture as yours.
If you don't want to clutter up the pictures of your 'Reverse colour wrecker truck', the best method of protecting your images, is a very old idea but it works, you simply write your name and address on a card and place it near the model, take several pictures to make up a set, make a duplicate set and post that duplicate set, back to your own house, that way you have a dated post mark on the envelope and a set of pictures with your name on them. Later if you see pictures on the net somewhere, you can compare it with your set and start to enquire as to where the picture has come from or who is using it.
Overall control of the use of pictures, should remain with the picture taker, its worth spending a little time and effort to make your pictures unique to you, this way they can be identified as yours, in any future missuse.
By no means have I covered everything on this subject, but hopefully I have given some extra guidance and I am sure this will be talked about again, the subject of copyright of pictures is important, so any forum members who have experienced any issues with seeing their images used eleswhere, please tell us your story, but I don't think there will be many of you, it just does not happen as much as we think it does.
GHOSTHUNTER.