Re: So which Scorpion 1-75s are the real ones?
Posted: Thu Mar 13, 2014 3:49 am
Discussions like this really draw my interest so I thought I would try to spur this one on a bit by throwing my thoughts out there. Discussions like this are also hard to have publically because it is so easy to offend or upset someone who may have a variant in their collection which may be proposed as being questionable. That is not my intention and my comments are only meant in the interest of academic discussion.
Alex, I have seen pictures of the 52 Dodge Charger, 47 Beach Hopper and 68 Porsche with (front)45/(rear)scorpion labels. I have never seen these models in hand and do not know their original origin. I personally do not consider them production models and I do not think they belong in the definitive source guides. Perhaps people who own these can share them and offer their perspective if they want to.
Fixer to address your purple Dragster scorpion, I believe that is a widely accepted variation, as is the org-red issue with similar labels. I have seen these pictured on metallic red issue models but I do not think that is a production issue, similar to the previously mentioned models.
The wear on yours is prevalent but appears proportionate to the model. The white nicks on the labels edges are fairly uniform around the circumference of the rear label and more heavy on the front of the front label (less significant on the back half where it is protected by the motor). Your purple issue has the labels oriented in the same direction, which is how other issues of the purple I have seen are. Interestingly, all of the org-red issue with the scorpion labels I have seen are in opposite orientation. I assume this is because the models where produced at different times (purple later) and the model makers were instructed different ways. Bottom line, looks authentic to me and besides, what a silly model to try and fake because you would use 2 scorpion labels to do it
Pierkemimi, thanks for posting your scorpion models. I hope you do not mind me commenting on them. From my understanding, the “68” label was the default label Lesney applied to the Porsche during its life. There were shortages of 68 labels and during these times other labels including the “45” (from the 45 Group 6), “137” (from the 15 VW saloon) and scorpion label where used on the model. The model you show does not make logical sense to me because the scorpion labels would only be used when there were no 68 labels. And while this is tough to be sure of in your picture, the front 68 label and its edges seem well preserved. The rear scorpion label seems to have a lot of asymmetric whitening along the rear that catches my eye. You are best able to see this in hand, what do you think about it?
The other model you show is quite an interesting lighter bronze color. I am curious if this is uniform onto the base of the car and inside all of the deep bottom recesses of the casting. In fact, can you just peel off the scorpion label and tell me what color the paint is underneath (Ha ha, don’t do that!). My only reason to comment on that is the model paint looks quite dull/faded and the label seems to remain quite bright. It just strikes me as a little disproportionate. However, the front of the label does seem the most damaged and that is what I would expect as it was rammed into other cars on a track. I cannot see from your picture if there is subtle lifting of one edge of that label or small creases/lines on the label but those are what I would be looking for very closely.
-David
Alex, I have seen pictures of the 52 Dodge Charger, 47 Beach Hopper and 68 Porsche with (front)45/(rear)scorpion labels. I have never seen these models in hand and do not know their original origin. I personally do not consider them production models and I do not think they belong in the definitive source guides. Perhaps people who own these can share them and offer their perspective if they want to.
Fixer to address your purple Dragster scorpion, I believe that is a widely accepted variation, as is the org-red issue with similar labels. I have seen these pictured on metallic red issue models but I do not think that is a production issue, similar to the previously mentioned models.
The wear on yours is prevalent but appears proportionate to the model. The white nicks on the labels edges are fairly uniform around the circumference of the rear label and more heavy on the front of the front label (less significant on the back half where it is protected by the motor). Your purple issue has the labels oriented in the same direction, which is how other issues of the purple I have seen are. Interestingly, all of the org-red issue with the scorpion labels I have seen are in opposite orientation. I assume this is because the models where produced at different times (purple later) and the model makers were instructed different ways. Bottom line, looks authentic to me and besides, what a silly model to try and fake because you would use 2 scorpion labels to do it
Pierkemimi, thanks for posting your scorpion models. I hope you do not mind me commenting on them. From my understanding, the “68” label was the default label Lesney applied to the Porsche during its life. There were shortages of 68 labels and during these times other labels including the “45” (from the 45 Group 6), “137” (from the 15 VW saloon) and scorpion label where used on the model. The model you show does not make logical sense to me because the scorpion labels would only be used when there were no 68 labels. And while this is tough to be sure of in your picture, the front 68 label and its edges seem well preserved. The rear scorpion label seems to have a lot of asymmetric whitening along the rear that catches my eye. You are best able to see this in hand, what do you think about it?
The other model you show is quite an interesting lighter bronze color. I am curious if this is uniform onto the base of the car and inside all of the deep bottom recesses of the casting. In fact, can you just peel off the scorpion label and tell me what color the paint is underneath (Ha ha, don’t do that!). My only reason to comment on that is the model paint looks quite dull/faded and the label seems to remain quite bright. It just strikes me as a little disproportionate. However, the front of the label does seem the most damaged and that is what I would expect as it was rammed into other cars on a track. I cannot see from your picture if there is subtle lifting of one edge of that label or small creases/lines on the label but those are what I would be looking for very closely.
-David